I have been perusing presidential inaugural addresses through history.
George Washington gave his first inaugural address from a Wall Street balcony in 1789, discussing the debate over the relative powers of state and federal government, and calling on Congress to "avoid every alteration [to the Constitution] which might endanger the benefits of a united and effective government, or which ought to await the future lessons of experience."
John Adams, inaugurated in Philadelphia in 1797, noted that he was abroad working as an ambassador when the Constitution was written, had the luxury of reading it without any personal involvement in its production, and "I read it with great satisfaction, as the result of good heads prompted by good hearts."
The Constitution was still topic one when Thomas Jefferson took the oath at the partially completed U.S. Capitol in 1801. "Though the will of the majority is in all cases to prevail," he said, "the minority possess their equal rights, which equal law must protect."
Four years later, for the first time, a new issue rose to the fore. Jefferson had the Louisiana Purchase to defend, and did. "Is it not better that the opposite bank of the Mississippi should be settled by our own brethren and children than by strangers of another family? With which should we be most likely to live in harmony?"
Jefferson stood in the crowd with 10,000 other citizens when James Madison was inaugurated in 1809. Madison, who would have to flee the White House during a British invasion in the War of 1812, entered office determined to keep America out of European conflicts, "to maintain sincere neutrality...to exclude foreign intrigues...so degrading to all countries."
The next several inaugural addresses all refer to the issue of settlers and Indians, usually adopting a kindly view toward Indians which, however, also usually included the idea of encouraging them to adopt the newer inhabitants' ways. James Monroe, in 1817, also referred to the Barbary pirates, though he called them the Barbary Powers.
In 1825, John Quincy Adams, son of a Founding Father, became president of a nation with territory "from sea to sea" and a population triple what it was when the republic was formed. "If there have been those who doubted whether a confederated representative democracy were a government competent to the wise and orderly management of the common concerns of a mighty nation," he said, "those doubts have now been dispelled."
Andrew Jackson, four years later, promised respect for states' rights and to work to lower the federal debt. The near-riot that attended the inaugural partying that day -- Jackson's supporters trashed the White House and the president himself climbed through a window to escape the melee -- has left us with the idea that Jackson himself was a bumpkin, but his address had much same tone as its predecessors.
Martin Van Buren, in 1837, noted that he was too young to have been around at the birth of the nation, but felt that the ideas of the founding fathers had been "verified by time," and said, "The principle that will govern me...is a strict adherence to the letter and spirit of the Constitution as it was designed by those who framed it."
In 1841, William Henry Harrison, 68, spoke for an hour and 45 minutes in a snowstorm, then partied late into the night. A month later he was dead of pneumonia. Though there are no soundbites in his blizzard of words, it is actually a fairly interesting discourse on the Constitutional limits of executive power as compared to ancient Greece and Rome, and to the power grabs of Caesar, Cromwell and Bolivar.
In 1845, James Polk spoke for states' rights, and warned against forcing Southern states to abandon slavery, though he never used the term. He promised to curb spending, saying, "Ours was intended to be a plain and frugal government."
In 1849, Zachary Taylor was first to refer to George Washington in an inaugural address as "the Father of his Country."
Franklin Pierce, the only president to choose to "affirm" rather than to "swear" the oath, took office in 1853. "The founders," he said, "dealt with things as they were presented to them...with a comprehensive wisdom which it will always be safe for us to consult."
In 1857, James Buchanan got right into the issue of the day, whether new states should be allowed to have slaves or not. He thought it should be up to them. In criticizing Congress for some of its actions on the matter, he became the first inaugural speaker to refer to Congress in any manner other than what be described as obsequious.
I read every inaugural address up to and through Lincoln's and can tell you that not one paragraph in any of them approaches the quality of writing that pervades Lincoln's addresses, which, please note, he wrote himself.
In 1861, Lincoln was still pleading with the Southern states to calm down and stick with the Union. He quoted both his own campaign speeches and the platform of his party to assure them that he did not intend to impose abolition on them. But he also argued that secession would be sedition. "One party to a contract may violate it," he said, "but does it not require all to lawfully rescind it?" He said North and South would live next to each other, and engage in commerce, whether they were united or not, and added, "Can aliens make treaties easier than friends can make laws?"
Four years later, in his second inaugural address, came the first great sound bite quote, "With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God give us to see the right." Less than two months later Lincoln was shot to death.
Some really boring inaugural addresses came in the years that followed, as the florid rhetoric that in the past had been placed in homage to the Constitution was instead aimed at transitory issues. But in 1905 Teddy Roosevelt said, "Much has been given us, and much will rightfully be expected from us," and in 1917 Woodrow Wilson declared America an imperial power with the words, "We are provincials no longer."
I realize, after reading dozens of these addresses, that most of these presidents were not thinking of posterity when they made their most memorable remarks, but were rather trying to use the occasion of their inauguration to shape the political debate of the day. That is what FDR was doing in 1933, in the Great Depression, when he said, "We have nothing to fear but fear itself," and that is what Ronald Reagan was doing in 1981 when he said, "Government is not the solution to our problem; government IS the problem."
Recent Comments