The cable network TV Land, in conjunction with the magazine Entertainment Weekly, has "compiled" a list of the 50 top TV icons. Slapped together would have been more like it.But lists are great for starting public discourse, since everyone is likely to disagree vehemently about some of the rankings, so why I don't I go ahead and get my dudgeon on.
Johnny Carson leads the list. He should be on the list, but higher than Lucille Ball or Walter Cronkite?
I've got no problem with the fact that Late Night host David Letterman made the list while Jay Leno did not, but Jon Stewart, while funny, is not yet an icon. The list has no room for any of four men on whose shoulders these other guys stand: Dick Cavett, Jack Paar, Joey Bishop and Steve Allen.
Carol Burnett, Ed Sullivan, Jackie Gleason and Flip Wilson made the list. I recently saw some old Flip Wilson shows and don't mind his inclusion. But I never cared for Milton Berle, and it's weird to see him listed but not the funnier and more pioneering Sid Caesar and Ernie Kovacs.
Lucille Ball is joined on the list by Bill Cosby, Mary Tyler Moore, Dick Van Dyke, Andy Griffith, Carroll O'Connor, Bob Newhart, Alan Alda, and some others who aren't in the same class but did make powerful impressions on TV, including William Shatner, Henry Winkler (surely Jim Nabors' Gomer Pyle is more iconic than the Fonz!), Roseanne, Jerry Seinfeld and Bea Arthur.
It seemed odd, however, to also see such names as Michael Landon, Heather Locklear, John Ritter, Sarah Jessica Parker, Sally Field and George Clooney, especially as the expensive of Raymond Burr from "Perry Mason" (not to mention "Ironsides"), James Arness from "Gunsmoke," which was on for 20 years for crying out loud, his brother Peter Graves from "Mission: Impossible" (not to mention "Biography") or even Donald J. Travanti from "Hill Street Blues."
And have these people forgotten Jack Lord?
The list includes Lassie, Homer Simpson, and Kermit the Frog, but I would like to have seen Rocky and Bullwinkle on the list as well. If you're raising children young enough to watch The Cartoon Network, you know how influential the Bullwinkle Show has been on contemporary animation writers.
From the world of news, Walter Cronkite made the list, and should have, given his incredible influence on public opinion and on the style of television news presentation at a time when there were only three networks and his newscast was top-rated, but there is no spot for David Brinkley, who was almost as influential at the time and was in the game way longer -- he was also perhaps the best writer TV news has ever had. Barbara Walters, who pioneered lead roles for women in electronic journalism, belongs on the list, but so does Edward R. Murrow, who almost invented broadcast field reporting.
From sports, the list includes Howard Cosell, the attorney who became an opinionated sports commentator (and -- trivia question -- hosted a variety show called Saturday Night Live for about five minutes, which is why the show we all know as Saturday Night Live debuted as NBC Saturday Night) but not John Madden, who is slightly less annoying and a lot more knowledgable than Cosell was, or Jim McKay of ABC's Wide World of Sports, whose smooth coverage of terrorism at the Olympics raised the bar for all sports journalists to come.
The list includes Simon Cowell of "American Idol" but not Ralph Edwards of "This is Your Life." Dick Clark of "American Bandstand" is on the list but not Groucho Marx from "You Bet Your Life." Bob Barker is on the list but not Gary Moore from "To Tell the Truth" or John Daly from "What's My Line?" But it's Groucho's omission that bugs me the most. He was as sharp-tongued as Simon but way wittier.
From daytime talk shows, Oprah made the list, and Ellen DeGeneres, but not Mike Douglas or Merv Griffin, who had the two pioneering syndicated talk shows, or Phil Donahue, who did the first major tabloid talk show, but at least they left off Jerry Springer and Geraldo Riviera. I'm not old enough to remember whether Mike Douglas or Merv Griffin came first but I'm old enough to remember that everyone who followed the two of them has repeated what they did first.
Recent Comments